Page last updated on Mon May 25 13:33:52 EDT 2015
Thu, 17 Nov 2011 11:26 AM EST

The locked-out National Basketball Players Association has filed two separate class-action antitrust lawsuits against the NBA league owners, one each in Minnesota and California, claiming Commissioner David Stern’s ultimatums have left them no other options.

Players Association attorney David Boies lays the blame totally on the league owners, saying that the players were willing to accept a lesser cut of basketball-related revenue but that owners insisted on receiving a bigger slice of the pie. Basketball odds

The players have now taken the matter to court, seeking “treble damages” against the league— that is, triple the amount of the more than $2 billion they would have made under a full 2011-12 season—for what they argue is irreparable harm done by preventing them from playing in their “very short” NBA careers (estimated to average about 5 years) by being locked out. The lockout is now in its 139th day. All different types of players are represented in the suits – free agents, contract players, and rookies.

Boies said the NBA lockout violates antitrust laws by refusing to allow players to work even though they were still under contract.

Boies said that Stern’s ultimatum to the now-disbanded union to accept the owners’ last proposal or face a harsher one “turned out to be a mistake” that strengthens the players’ case because it proves that the collective bargaining process had ended. He also acknowledged that the case could take months to reach a settlement. Basketball spreads

Boies insists the players have shown their willingness to negotiate throughout the entire process.

The NBA already has filed a pre-emptive lawsuit in New York seeking to prove the lockout is legal and will likely try to get the cases moved there to gain some legal traction.

Boies said he believes NBA players currently have a stronger case than NFL players did in their lawsuit. The NFL players decertification could have been argued as a sham because they walked out on the bargaining process before it was technically over and then brought litigation. Boies said that Stern’s actions left NBA players without any options other than seeking legal relief.

The California filing says that in 2007, Stern met with union negotiators and demanded the players reduce their revenue share from 57 percent to no more than 50 percent and “insisted on a much more restrictive salary cap, which would restrict the market for player services.”

Stern threatened at that meeting, according to the lawsuit, that the owners were “prepared to lock out the players for two years to get everything” that the NBA owners wanted and that “the deal would only get worse after the lockout.”

Players were willing to consent to the owners’ demands of a 50-50 split of basketball-related income—a transfer of about $280 million annually from their guaranteed 57 percent under the old deal—but only if the owners met them on their system wishes.

The lockout began on July 1. The season was supposed to begin on Nov. 1, but already games through Dec. 15 have been canceled and it is likely that the rest of the season will be cancelled as well.

Sponsored Links

Download Printable Schedules
Now you can download and print schedules for each sport so you can plan ahead and track your results.
BASEBALL 4/5/2015 - 6/4/2015
RK Team
Kansas City Royals
Houston Astros
Golden State Warriors
New York Yankees
Boston Red Sox
ATP - Roland Garros, Paris, FranceMURRAY, ANDY vs. ARGUELLO, FACUNDO08:35 AM PST
ATP - Roland Garros, Paris, FranceEDMUND, KYLE vs. ROBERT, STEPHANE08:45 AM PST
ATP - Roland Garros, Paris, FranceMANNARINO, ADRIAN vs. MELZER, JURGEN08:45 AM PST
ATP - Roland Garros, Paris, FranceKUZNETSOV, ANDREY vs. JAZIRI, MALEK08:55 AM PST
WTA - Roland Garros, Paris, FrancePLISKOVA, KAROLINA vs. ZHANG, SHUAI09:20 AM PST
WTA - Roland Garros, Paris, FranceSTEPHENS, SLOANE vs. WILLIAMS, VENUS09:25 AM PST
MLBKC Royals vs NY Yankees10:05 AM PST
MLBPhillies vs NY Mets10:10 AM PST
MLBRockies vs Reds10:10 AM PST
MLBAstros vs Orioles10:35 AM PST
MLBSF Giants vs Brewers11:10 AM PST
MLBRed Sox vs Twins11:10 AM PST
MLBNationals vs Cubs11:20 AM PST
MLBTigers vs Athletics1:05 PM PST
MLBRangers vs Indians1:10 PM PST
MLBDiamondbacks vs Cardinals1:15 PM PST
MLBMarlins vs Pirates4:05 PM PST
MLBWhite Sox vs Blue Jays4:05 PM PST
MLBMariners vs TB Rays4:10 PM PST
MLBBraves vs LA Dodgers5:10 PM PST
NBAWarriors vs Rockets6:00 PM PST
NHL - PlayoffsBlackhawks at Ducks6:00 PM PST
MLBSD Padres vs LA Angels6:05 PM PST